/sa/ - Sāhitya & Itihāsa

Board for discussions related to Literature and History.

0/4000

BharatChan Disclaimer

Notice

Before proceeding, please read and understand the following:

1. BharatChan is a user-generated content platform. The site owners do not claim responsibility for posts made by users.

2. By accessing this website, you acknowledge that content may not be suitable for all audiences.

3. You must follow BharatChan’s community guidelines and rules. Failure to do so may result in a ban.

4. By using BharatChan users agree to the use of cookies, mostly for session related to user.

A poster on BharatChan must abide by the following rules:

Sitewide Rules
You must be 18 or older to post.
Sharing personal details or engaging in doxing is strictly prohibited.
Political discussions should be confined to /pol/.
NSFW content is only allowed in /kama/.
Off-topic discussions, thread derailment, or spam may result in a ban and IP blacklist.
Pornographic content is strictly prohibited.
Any activity violating local laws is not allowed.
Acknowledge

Recent Posts

View

Disillusionment

View

heestory n shie

View

want to understand history and spirituality better

View

View

Temple of the Golden Pavilion

View

melancholy recommendations

View

chart thread

View

Is it reals

View

Bihari Pyscho

View

This month's reads

View

/lit/ bros, help me

View

Why do women love him?

View

GUYS IM GOING TO READ DOSTOVISKY for the first tim...

View

Gāndhâra Mahäjanapāda

View

Muhammad bin Tughlaq: the scizho king.

View

View

Despair and the last man

View

/MSART/ - Mega Sāhitya & Itihāsa Resources Thread

View

Passages

View

Based Wittgenstein

View

Brutal Cuckoldry in Karnataka’s Lingyat religion

View

My favorite book

View

View

sf

View

Were temples back in the day also painted

View

View

View

Kino psychology book thread

View

View

View

Brahmi Script General - /BSG/

View

Kino

View

It has begun….

View

Me

View

Doomer reading bucketlist

View

View

View

Kino Read

View

Which book should i read next

View

Sylvia Path…

View

View

Maratha Spirit - Faustian Spirit

View

View

Disillusionment

Anonymous

IN

4zPGo+

No.224

There is a certain kind of cognitive dissonance when I read western literature or even anything that isn't in relation with our culture. I enjoy them thoroughly but most do not remain relavent in relation to my daily life due to how different the circumstances that developed these works were.

I linger with the hope that there is still some obscure and experimental sahitya being developed that faces this question of schizo-culture head on. Literature reeks of eurocentricism but there is no doubt that there is a common denominator of universalization in the way ideas and concepts develop. But there is still some doubt in my mind.

Do people from /sa/ experience this?

ARYA

zvn2R0

No.225

>>224(OP)

>I enjoy them thoroughly but most do not remain relavent in relation to my daily life due to how different the circumstances that developed these works were.

'relevant' in what sense? usefulness? true-ness?

Most literature is moreso like a drink, say like wine. You don't drink it for its nutritional value - not to say there isn't any - but for everything except. You drink to enjoy it. (By most I mean the mode of literature consumed typically)

This aspect still is retained in books you read(in every book to some extent), otherwise they would be too coarse, too dry to swallow.

The thing is, a difference in circumstances doesn't prevent you from understanding those circumstances. This is hinged on what you mentioned in the last line: 'that there is a common denominator of universalisation in the way ideas and concepts develop.' But again, you do admit it. Well, but you must know if there was a difference in circumstances other than what you can immediately understand, you would intuitively acknowledge its difference and feel dissonance, so I don't get what you mean, you seemingly answer it yourself.

>Do people from /sa/ experience this?

this is experienced more in fiction than nonfiction which(nonfiction) is more 'general', in how it relates to everything.

Anonymous

IN

IWfDEv

No.226

>>225

>'relevant' in what sense? usefulness? true-ness?

Identification, which is a cheap "want", I admit.

But Literature and Art, in general, seem to work as getaways approaching some kind of objectivity.

>I don't get what you mean, you seemingly answer it yourself.

I'm aware, I didn't pose it as a question, it was more of a quasi-proclamation of the sentiment.

As you said, in order to be able to appreciate arts you forgo looking at mundane and trivial things that work as placeholders, to get to the heart of whatever the text is getting at, it's just one of those times when you feel no identification with anything whatsoever.

I'd guess that it has more to do with the times we live in, where everything is seemingly thrown out the window but there is still some resemblance, some ties to what was which makes it all the more overwhelming.